← Guides

How should quality leaders compare AI manufacturing software for batch review automation?

By Savi C., Co-Founder · Published Nov 17, 2026

Evaluation criteria

Use these as rows in your scoring sheet. Pharma is the main example, but the same criteria apply to devices, food, supplements and cosmetics.

Criterion

Record coverage

What good looks like

Reads handwritten and scanned paper, electronic batch records and system exports, not only data already inside its own system

Criterion

Basis for checks

What good looks like

Checks against your master record, specifications and release criteria, not a generic rule set

Criterion

Traceability

What good looks like

Every flag opens the exact source page or field, so a reviewer can confirm it in seconds

Criterion

Output for QA

What good looks like

A review-by-exception file: what was checked, what passed, and each exception with its evidence

Criterion

Human control

What good looks like

The tool proposes and the quality unit decides. It cannot release, reject or close anything on its own

Criterion

Audit trail

What good looks like

Records who reviewed and accepted each flag, and when, in line with Part 11 and Annex 11 expectations

Criterion

Validation support

What good looks like

The vendor explains intended use, how performance is tested, and what evidence they give you for a risk-based assurance approach

Criterion

Fit with existing systems

What good looks like

Works on top of your QMS, MES, LIMS and ERP without forcing a migration

Criterion

Deployment

What good looks like

Offers the hosting your IT and data policies need: vendor cloud, your cloud, on-premises or air-gapped

Tests to run in a demo

On your own records

  • Supply five to ten executed batch records your team has already reviewed, with known errors, and do not say where the errors are
  • Include at least one handwritten record with corrections, crossings out and attached printouts
  • Count what the tool found, what it missed, and what it flagged that was not an error
  • Check that a missed signature, a late entry and an out-of-range value each get caught

On evidence and control

  • Click five random flags and confirm each opens the right source page
  • Ask how a reviewer accepts, rejects or comments on a flag, and where that is recorded
  • Change a specification limit and confirm the next review uses the new value
  • Ask what happens when the tool cannot read a page. It should say so, not guess

Red flags

A demo that only uses the vendor's sample records. Clean typed samples tell you nothing about how a tool handles your handwriting, your forms or your master records.

Claims that the software releases batches or replaces QA review. Under 21 CFR 211.192 the quality control unit reviews and approves production and control records before release, and in the EU a Qualified Person certifies the batch. A tool that blurs that line creates inspection risk, not savings.

Flags with no link to the source. If a reviewer has to search the record to confirm each flag, you have moved the work rather than removed it.

No clear answer on validation. Ask how the vendor tests performance, how changes to the model are controlled, and what documentation you receive. FDA's computer software assurance guidance and GAMP 5 both support a risk-based approach, but you still need evidence that the tool works for its intended use.

A requirement to move every record into the vendor's system before anything works. That turns a review project into a migration project.

How Litewave fits

Litewave is an AI review layer for regulated manufacturers. It reads handwritten and scanned paper records, electronic batch records and system exports, checks executed batch records against your master record, specifications and release criteria, and produces a review-by-exception file for QA with every flag linked to its source page. It works on top of your existing QMS, MES, LIMS and ERP, and runs in Litewave cloud, your cloud or on-premises, with an air-gapped option in which no data leaves your network.

Litewave proposes, qualified people approve. It never releases a batch on its own. At a leading global generic API manufacturer, batch disposition became 85% faster, as described in our published case study. For more on the method, see our guides What is review by exception for batch records? and How do you validate an AI tool in a GxP environment?

Questions we get asked

What is the single most useful test when comparing tools?

A blind test on your own reviewed batch records with known errors. It shows real detection, false flags and how each tool handles your formats, which no feature list can.

Should we buy an EBR or MES instead of AI review software?

They do different jobs. An EBR or MES controls execution; AI review checks completed records, including paper. Our guide AI record review vs an EBR or MES: do you need both? covers when you need one, the other, or both.

Can AI batch review software release a batch?

It should not. Release stays with the quality unit in the US and with the Qualified Person in the EU. AI review prepares the evidence and the exceptions for that decision.

Do these criteria apply outside pharma?

Yes. Medical device, food, supplement and cosmetics manufacturers face the same questions about record coverage, traceability, human control and validation, even though the regulations differ.

Sources

  1. 21 CFR 211.192, Production record review (eCFR)
  2. 21 CFR Part 11, Electronic records; electronic signatures (eCFR)
  3. EudraLex Volume 4, Annex 11, Computerised Systems
  4. FDA, Computer Software Assurance for Production and Quality Management System Software (February 2026)
  5. ISPE, GAMP 5 Guide, second edition
  6. Litewave case study, batch disposition at a leading global generic API manufacturer